The Easter Bunny Debacle
You'll recall last Christmas season I had some inner conflict about
Santa. Now that Ella has reached an age where questions abound about how Santa and the Easter Bunny operate, I feel like more lies are told to cover up the lies. I know it's all about childhood innocence and the magic, blah, blah, blah--but I had kind of told myself that Santa I could do, the Easter Bunny I was going to downplay. I was hoping that we could have our Easter traditions and the Easter Bunny wouldn't even come into the equation. I decided I wouldn't deny the existence of the Easter Bunny, but I wasn't going to hype it up or concoct a whole bunch of lies to protect him.
Over a week ago, we're all driving in the car when the following exchange happens:
E: Mom, Ms. Susan says that the Easter Bunny will come to our house.
Me: Oh, she did? Hmmm. Well, really the Easter Bunny is about the spirit of Easter. He's a fun character that comes out at Easter time.
B: (under his breath) It's a slippery slope, dear.
Silence.
E: So he won't come to our house?
Me: We'll do lots of fun things at our house.
Silence.
I looked in my rear view mirror to see Ella pensively staring out the window.
My heart broke.
In a matter of 10 seconds I feared that I had killed the Easter bunny. I felt a portion of my daughter's innocence evaporate. What had I done??? I kept replaying the conversation back in my head. Maybe Ella hadn't understood what I was saying. I mean, I was vague enough, right? She's only 5-years-old--did she interpret that to mean there was no Easter bunny? Why didn't I think this through more?
And so, I decided I somehow had to resurrect the Easter bunny. The next day as a way of assuaging my guilt, I went to Target to buy all kinds of things for the Easter Bunny to bring. Gobs of candy, stickers, Polly pockets, bubbles, nail polish, lip gloss, Easter socks--this Easter Bunny was going to rock. The next task was to casually slip in to conversation that the Easter Bunny exists.
So I waited for Ella to bring it up again. Surely she would. Ella is an extremely cerebral child. She analyzes everything. She'll ask you an onslaught of questions--internalize your answers for a day or two, come back with new questions. No stone is left unturned. She wants logical explanations to everything. Perhaps this is why Santa and the Easter Bunny have been difficult--she wants to know everything. (The conversations about death from the past month and a half after my Grandma's passing is material for another post.)
But Ella never brought the Easter bunny up again.
It didn't help that after I came out of my bathroom from blow-drying my hair one morning, Ella sat on my bed and said, "Mom, was I supposed to see that Polly Pocket thing in your closet?"
"Um, no" I replied. "That was a surprise. I guess it's not any more."
Great. More cover-ups were needed. I couldn't put the Polly Pocket in her basket from the Easter Bunny, because she knows I bought it. I had a chalk-full week and couldn't go exchange it for another one or get something else. Plus she was on spring break and she certainly couldn't accompany me to the store. Aaargh.
So last Thursday, while Brian was working late, Ella and I started dying Easter eggs. This was it--we had to talk about the Easter Bunny.

Me: So have you thought about what the Easter Bunny might bring you?
E: (eyes wide open) But Mom, I thought you said the Easter Bunny wasn't real!
Shoot. I was right. How could I have been so heartless?
Me: Oh Ella, I'm sorry. The Easter Bunny will come to our house. I'm sorry I made you think he wouldn't.
E: Oh my gosh. I'm so excited. I hope he brings me some more pet shop animals and lots of candy. How does he get in our house? Does he come down the chimney like Santa? It's a good thing he's a bunny and can hop fast to get to everyone's house...
And the deluge of questions continued. So I swallowed, answered her questions the best I could and basked in the joy of a young child so eager to believe.
The Easter Bunny now lives again. A certain little girl anxiously awaited his arrival, not falling asleep for the night until at least 1:30am (she outlasted me). But he ate our carrots (left in front of the fireplace) and filled our baskets with goodies.


PS- A big thanks goes to the Harpers for granting us the use of your bunny for pics.
PPS- Is it possible my children will need therapy by the time I'm done raising them?